Re: Robots in Diguise (IDW ongoing series)
Posted: Mon Mar 25, 2013 9:50 am
How does the descent and fall of a character defined by his blind loyalty to his faction’s existence not count as ‘genuine’ character development? “He who fights with monsters should take care, lest he himself become a monster.” That’s friggin’ classic, and given everything we’ve been shown about Prowl in IDW up until issue 4 of this series, made perfect sense as a direction for him to go. Maybe it makes readers like you *feel bad* to see a character you categorize as ‘heroic’ go down such a path, but it’s sure as hell more interesting than “Prowl was kind of a bad guy but now he’s going to be a good guy because he feels sad that some of the other Autobots think he’s a jerk.”andersonh1 wrote:I take some offense to this mischaracterization. I haven't been sitting around hoping Prowl wasn't getting any character development. I've been reading this book month after month being unhappy that Prowl had become a fascist thug, no better than the Decepticons he supposedly hates. That wasn't character development, that was character destruction. I'm delighted that it turned out to be Bombshell the whole time, and I look forward to seeing Prowl grow and change after being put through the ringer the way he has been. That will be genuine character development.
I don’t see how he’s been ‘put through the wringer’, he got body-jacked in issue 4 and has been effectively absent from the story ever since. Now he’ll be back to issue 4 spec (if Barber doesn’t just kill him rendering this whole stupid story moot), and go back to being one of the faceless masses of good guy Autobots who exclusively fight against Decepticon evil just the way you like.
Watching an authoritarian figure who’s past his time descending trying to maintain his faction’s power, eventually becoming the very thing he had fought to stop (not to mention exactly the sort of Autobot who would’ve been prosecuted in an Aequitas trial, which would’ve been a fantastic bit of irony) would’ve been ‘putting him through the wringer’. All Prowl got here was a reset button to put him back to generic good guy status.
How is ‘Decepticons acting like Decepticons’ an interesting story? We’ve seen that a jillion times before. What we haven’t seen is Decepticons genuinely trying to turn to sincere political leadership, or Autobots going to extreme lengths to maintain the ‘victory’ they fought for and losing themselves in the process. I fail to see how that isn’t an interesting story.The story we've been given is vastly better than the "Prowl descends to the dark side" type of story that you wanted to read. Decepticons are acting like Decepticons, using deceit, subterfuge and infiltration to destabilize society to take over. Sounds like consistency and continuity to me, and I love that I didn't see it coming.
Except that Prowl’s characterization in IDW has never been about ‘basic moral standards’, it’s always been about stringent loyalty to the Autobot brand itself, and his willingness to uphold its authority and appearances at the cost of any personal moral bias. Did you completely miss the AHM Coda issue where he rebuilt a beloved old man into a propaganda machine? What about LSotW where he sends a bunch of green recruits to be brutally killed so that he can destroy evidence of unsavory Autobot activities? This has always been Prowl’s characterization, until Barber decided that that just wasn’t good enough and he had to try to ‘fix’ Prowl so people reading wouldn’t feel bad about how mean he was being.andersonh1 wrote:Who ever said he was a "generic, happy go lucky good guy"? Not me. He doesn't have to be that in order to uphold some basic moral standards, surely.
First off, how does doing that make Bumblebee that bad guy? Not only was Horri-Bull assaulting a civilian at the time and needed to be stopped, but have you seriously been watching and reading Transformers since G1 and have never seen an Autobot kill a Decepticon before? You know it’s a war story, right?And Bumblebee blew Horri-bull's head off in issue #1. He's not much better.
And anyway, Bumblebee didn’t actually kill Horri-Bull, it was retconned out to be Skywarp the next issue, in a move that really should have made it clear to me what a pussy Barber is about these things.