Re: Comics are Awesome III
Posted: Wed Jan 27, 2016 8:06 pm
Yeah I do and that shouldn't be an unreasonable expectation. There was a time when crazy back writes, over writes, rewrites, downwrites, outwrites. soft reboots, hard reboots, partial reboots and total reboots never happened. Comics were a single cohesive narrative that could reference stories going back years or even decades. DC has gotten so bad with this shit that I don't think THEY could even make heads or tails of what's in and what's not at this point. And frankly, for me, as someone who's not really in the hobby, if I was looking for a jumping on point, it would be really REALLY difficult to find one. The other problem with segmenting everything like this is this: (see below)Dominic wrote:Do you really expect stuff to stick for more than a few years anyway? There is plenty of stuff from the last few years that may as well not be counted. That does not mean those comics are inherently bad. But, they are not relevant.mean, honestly, if I thought for one second that the new Superman or Spiderman or whoever book was going to have the staying power and that the stories told were still going to be relevant and part of the narrative for more than just a few years later?
Dominic wrote:You have "zero Superman comics"?And I already like some of their characters. Superman is my favorite Super hero. And yet, I have literally 0 Superman comics.
How can you be a Superman fan and not have any comics? If nothing else, what is the point? Have you read "All Star Superman" or "Red Son" (two of the best "Superman" comics ever)? The "triangle number" stuff that Anderson mentions was an ambitious run. "Final Crisis" was heavily focused on Superman as an idea.
That is correct, I have ZERO Superman comics. I have not read "Red Son" or "All Star Superman". I was actually planning to read them at some point but at the time, the budget just wasn't there. It is there now, but why the hell would I want to go back and read stories that DC is now telling me never happened? What's the point? I want to read stories that are relevant and going to STAY relevant. But I really can't because the big two Marvel and DC reboot and etcha sketch crap so often that it literally just insta-kills the very minimal interest I had to begin with. So again, with comics in general being a passive interest to me at best, why am I going to spend money on something that doesn't matter and didn't happen when I can literally think of like 100 other things that I would rather spend my money on?
And that's really my point. As an outside observer of the hobby and not being someone who is regularly a part of the hobby, but occasionally has an interest in it, it's hard to maintain that passing interest when I'm constantly being told that whatever I read isn't going to matter or be referenced or have even happened in a very short period of time. Of course, if Marvel and DC would generally keep their titles separate from each other and not cross over all the time, that would help. Case in point: I actually had a Superman comic at one point. Back when "Darkest Night" was going on. I couldn't tell you what issue it was or if it was a one shot or if it was just an issue from a series and... yeah, honestly, again, that's part of the problem. I should be able to tell you all of that. I'm a Trekkie, nitpicking and remembering this kind of minutiae is exactly what my people do. But, yeah, if I want to read comic books, I'd like to be able to just pick a title featuring a character that I'm interested in and be able to star reading it with some sense that what I was reading was going to matter and have some longevity to it and that I could also just read about that one said character without having to read about a bunch of other nobodies that I don't care about.
To answer the question of "if you're not reading the comics, what's the point?" well that's the problem with Superman, Batman and Spiderman: 75% of their fan base doesn't read comic books. Seriously, how many people do you see with their logos on a tshirt or car logo or what ever? Next time you see one, ask if they read comics. I'll bet the answer is no. That's mostly because those characters have transcended into other mediums. Movies, TV, video games, etc... so there's plenty of other avenues and outlets to enjoy those characters without having to actually set foot in a comic shop. For me, my introduction to Superman were the Christopher Reeve movies and I still maintain those are the best Super hero movies and they will never top them. Don't get me wrong, I like the MCU, but none of it holds a candle to 78 Superman I and II. Also, I didn't make up that statistic (about the % of fans). It was told to me by a guy who worked in a comic shop for years and had an encyclopedic knowledge of comic books, so yeah, I trust that he's probably right on that one. And it would be hard for me to argue that since I fit into that category anyway. Anyway, yeah, my enjoyment of Superman as a character over the years has not been from comics but from his appearances in other media.
Uh yeah, I can, because the definition of "good" is subjective and differs from person to person. You all know me well enough here to know that I usually don't care much about what goes on behind the scenes of my fiction. I tend to follow properties that I'm interested in rather than writers or editors or directors or what have you. But, even I can't hide my head in the sand to what's going on in the industry because it has reached a point that it has actively pushed me out of the hobby. For me, a "good" comic, at least one that I'm going to commit to spending money on and reading every month, has to have stories that are entertaining, fun, consistent and be a cohesive narrative that is going to have some longevity. And look, it's not like I haven't tried before. I bought in for that Nightcrawler series only to have that cancelled after 12 issues. Thor went back to legacy numbering after 20 issues (which conveniently was around the time when the budget wasn't there any more), and then there was Ultimates which started to suffer from too many delays caused me to lose interest in that one.... Anyway, yeah, I've tried and it hasn't gone well and with the trends I see talked about on here, now is a terrible time to try to jump back into it. So yeah, I actually tried. Marvel and even DC had my money for a while but they just kept pulling the same stupid crap so often that I decided to get out of the hobby, got rid of all comics that aren't either TF or MOTU and I've honestly never regretted it.Dominic wrote:You cannot complain that there are no good comics if you are not reading them.
I also want to address the question of "do you really expect any story to be relevant a year later?" Honestly, the fact that you've asked that question seriously, with a (presumably) straight face, is a symptom of a HUGE problem with the fandom. In other words, comics as an industry and a medium would probably be better if the fandom that actually does keep coming back would stop supporting their habits. Marvel and DC are just going to keep pulling the same gimmicky bullshit year after year because... fans tolerate it and keep coming back. And worse, is that apparently the fans have become so numb to the bullshit that it's incredulous to think that anyone with a casual interest but not actively in the hobby would think to expect or even want something different. That's a problem! Yeah, you're damned right I expect different and you know what? I get it! Every month from IDW's TF books. They've had the license for over ten years now and when things happen, they stick! Dead characters don't come back! Seriously, I can name ten off the top of my head that are dead and haven't returned. That sure as hell doesn't happen with Marvel or DC! Oh and they often reference stories from before, sometimes from years ago! OMG!! What a concept! Yeah, IDW gets my money every month because quite frankly they're knocking it out of the park for what the big two SHOULD be doing! Ok, yeah, MOTU is technically a DC title, but it's not really considered to be part of the actual DCU. Like we're not going to see a movie of Batman vs. Superman vs. He-Man anytime soon (although that would be awesome and I would go broke watching the hell out of that).
Anyway, that was way longer of a post than I intended, but hey, this is what us, the casual fans feel like and I thought I would offer this perspective. And this a massive problem when you consider that with the success of comic book movies, Marvel and DC now have even more legions of potential readers out there. People that are now fans of their characters but haven't set foot in a comic shop ever. It should be REALLY easy to get them to start buying, but are they? No. and most of the crap I've talked about here is why.